Best Overall
KEEN Newport H2
Key details
- Type
- Closed-toe sport sandal
- Water Handling
- Water-friendly
- Packaged Weight
- 2.54 lb
A closed toe looks like a small design choice until you've watched a jig head skitter across a boat deck. The Newport H2 is the only sandal in this group that puts a bumper between your toes and whatever is rolling around, and that bumper is why it goes on first when we're headed out on a boat or picking our way along a rocky shoreline.
It's our top pick for more than toe protection. The footbed carries more arch support than anything else here, and we felt the difference during the long standing hours of a slow tide, when a flatter sandal starts reminding you it's there. They also behave the way a water sandal should: they drain, they don't hold a puddle under the heel, and wet straps don't turn into a slick surface against your foot.
Getting them on is the honest annoyance. The heel strap has no give, so it takes two hands and a couple of extra seconds; loosen it before you step in rather than fighting it one-handed on a rocking deck. They're also heavier than the mesh sandals here — the listing puts the packaged pair at 2.54 pounds, and that weight is the price of all that structure. Fish calm water from a stable boat and you may decide the trade isn't worth it.
Pros
- Closed toe shields against hooks and rock
- Strongest arch support in this group
- Drains and dries like a water sandal
Cons
- Stitching has come apart on some pairs
We recommend the Newport H2 to anyone fishing from a boat or off rocks: closed-toe protection and the best support in this group are worth the fiddly pull-on.