Best Overall
Columbia Benton Springs Full Zip
Key details
- Brand
- Columbia
- Fabric
- Fleece
- Closure
- Full zip
Midweight is the word we keep landing on for the Benton Springs: warm enough for a 50-degree morning, thin enough to vanish under a rain shell without bunching at the shoulders. That band of weather is where most fleece actually gets worn, and this jacket sits squarely in the middle of it. It's the one we reach for when we don't want to think about the forecast.
The shape is better than the price suggests. The cut narrows slightly at the waist instead of hanging straight, so it looks deliberate over jeans and doesn't bulk up under a vest. Sleeves run long, and the elastic at the wrist keeps the extra length off your hands — a small thing that saves a lot of cuff-shoving.
One detail to know before you order: the black isn't a true black. It reads as a soft charcoal, which is lovely on its own and a nuisance if you're matching it to something specific.
Below about 40 degrees this becomes a midlayer rather than a jacket, and that's the honest limit of it. Above that — school runs, dog walks, a cold office, a September hike — it's the piece that ends up in the car.
Pros
- Warm for fall, thin enough to layer
- Slightly shaped cut that flatters
- Elastic cuffs manage long sleeves
- Holds up to regular wear and washing
Cons
- Runs large; size down if you're between
If you want one fleece that works under a shell on a cold morning and over a T-shirt at your desk, this is the one we tell people to buy.