Best Overall
Merrell Moab 3
Key details
- Department
- Women's
- Model Number
- J035894
- Package Dimensions
- 13.35 x 9.02 x 5.08 inches; 2.6 pounds
There is no break-in period with the Moab 3. We took a pair out of the box and onto a rocky, root-crossed trail and came back without a hot spot, which is not something every shoe here manages. The toe box is the generous part — it leaves room for a thick sock without pressing on the outside of the foot, and it's the shape to choose if a wide forefoot has made hiking shoes miserable before. Sizing runs true, with enough volume that a heavy sock doesn't crowd your toes.
Underfoot is where it separates itself from the rest of this group. The arch support is the most convincing of the shoes we recommend, and it's the pair we reach for when the trail turns rocky or the descent gets steep: it stays stable underfoot instead of letting you feel every stone. Traction held on wet rock and loose gravel, and the tread doesn't skate when you step from stone to dirt. Build quality backs that up — nothing on the shoe felt like it was going to be the first thing to fail.
What you trade for that is weight. The Moab 3 is the beefier shoe beside the Siren Edge 3 — the listing puts its shipping weight at 2.6 pounds against 1.74 — and on a flat, fast walk you feel the extra shoe. Carry a pack or hike rough ground and the trade flips: the extra structure is what holds your feet together on a long descent. Lightweight it is not; unbothered by a hard trail, it very much is.
Pros
- No break-in before your first hike
- Roomy toe box leaves space for thick socks
- Supportive arch that holds on rocky ground
- Tread grips wet rock and loose gravel
Cons
- The priciest pick in this group
For rocky trails and long days with a pack, the Moab 3 is the pair we hand people first: supportive, roomy, and comfortable without a break-in.