Best Overall
Weber Jumbo Joe 18-Inch
Key details
- Fuel
- Charcoal
- Weight
- 18 lb
- Cooking Area
- 240 square inches
- Grate Diameter
- 18.5 inches
The detail that turns this kettle into a portable grill is the lid lock. The lid clamps down, the whole thing lifts by one handle, and the ash stays in the pan instead of in the trunk. At 18 pounds it is a one-person carry from the car to the picnic table, and what you set down is a real 18.5-inch kettle with 240 square inches of grate rather than a tray on legs.
We put it first because nothing else here cooks this much food this well. Six burgers fit with room to move them, a whole rack of babybacks goes under the lid, and because the lid exists you can bank coals to one side and cook indirect, which is the move that separates a grill from an open bed of charcoal. The aluminum dampers give you a low setting too, and the low end matters more than the top for anything thicker than a steak.
Charcoal is the cost of admission. You pack a bag of briquettes and a chimney, you allow twenty minutes of lead time, and you need somewhere to tip the ash, because the pan catches it but does not seal it. Against a tabletop gas grill that is more work per meal and, we think, a better meal.
Cleanup is the quiet advantage: lift the one-piece grate, tip the ash pan, and wipe the enamel out. There is no grease tray to fish from under a burner and no igniter to stop working, which is most of why it asks so little of you between trips.
Pros
- Lid locks shut for one-hand carrying
- 240 square inches cooks for four to six
- Lid and dampers allow true indirect cooking
- Porcelain enamel stands up to heat and weather
Cons
- Legs rust and loosen when stored outdoors
It is the grill we point most people to: it carries by its handle, feeds four to six, and cooks indirect like a full kettle.