Best Overall
Wordens Original Rooster Tail
Key details
- Pack
- 1 lure
- Tail
- Pulsating hackle
- Blade
- Brass, silver, or copper
- Length And Weight
- 2 1/4 in, 1/8 oz
This is the lure we reach for first, and it earns that with fewer parts than anything else here: a weighted in-line body, one blade on a clevis, and a hackle tail that pulses as it turns rather than whirring like a propeller. The one we fished is 2 1/4 inches and 1/8 ounce, which is the size that catches stream trout, perch, and smallmouth in the same afternoon without changing anything but the retrieve.
The blade is turning almost as soon as the lure starts moving, and the treble is sharp enough to set on a fish that only slaps at it. Consistency is the real difference between this and the ten-packs: the blade sits square on the shaft, the body has shrugged off rocks that would have chipped a painted kit lure, and the hackle still swings after a few fish instead of matting into a knot.
You pay for that in volume, because a pack is one lure in one color and one size. On a snaggy river, carry three. The white body we fished is a good place to start, since it reads as a baitfish in clear water and stays visible in stained water in a way that flash alone doesn't manage.
Pros
- Blade turns on the slowest retrieve
- Sharp treble straight out of the pack
- Hackle tail keeps its action after fish
- Catches trout, perch, bass, and panfish
Cons
- Sold singly, so a lost color stays lost
We recommend it without a hedge: it spins on the slowest retrieve, hooks sharply out of the pack, and catches whatever is holding in front of it.