Best Overall
Merrell All Out Blaze Aero Sport
Key details
- Model
- All Out Blaze Aero Sport
- Shoe Type
- Sport hiking water shoe
- Department
- Men's
Most water shoes are a neoprene sock with a rubber sole stuck on the bottom, and they feel like it the moment the trail tilts uphill. The Merrell All Out Blaze Aero Sport is a hiking shoe first, with laces, a structured upper, and a mesh body that lets water back out instead of holding it against your foot. That is why we put it at the top of this list: it is the one pair here you can hike in, not just wade in.
The mesh earns its keep in heat. Air moves through it constantly, so it never turns into the warm puddle a coated water shoe becomes on a July afternoon, and the toe box is genuinely wide, with room to spread out on a descent instead of jamming against the front. Feet that usually complain about cramped water shoes tend to stop complaining in these.
Grip is where cheap pairs give themselves away. On wet rock and wet boat decks the sole finds an edge, and the shoe has come through daily wear without the upper separating or the sole peeling, the two failures that show up at the budget end of this category.
Sizing is the thing to sort before you order: these run generous, and going down half a size is usually the fix. Past that, it is more shoe than a hotel pool or a lazy float trip needs, and for that the cheaper picks here do the job without you minding the salt.
Pros
- Mesh upper drains and dries fast
- Grip holds on wet rock and decks
- Wide toe box with room on descents
- Survives daily wear past a season
Cons
- Priced above most of the field
Our top pick for anyone whose hike crosses water: a proper hiking shoe with a mesh upper, a wide toe box, and grip that holds on wet rock and wet boat decks.