Best Overall
Columbia Ice Maiden II
Key details
- Model
- Ice Maiden II
- Style
- Snow boot
- Department
- Women's
Warmth is the easy part of a winter boot. Warmth you can wear for two hours without your socks going clammy is the harder trick, and the Ice Maiden II is the pair here that gets the balance right. We wore them through slushy sidewalks and long, cold waits outdoors and never got that baked, overheated feeling that has you kicking a boot off the moment you are inside. For a boot this warm, that surprised us.
The wet-weather side is just as composed. Snow and slush stay out, a soaked sidewalk does not reach the sock, and the boot does not get heavier as the day goes on. Comfort holds too: this is one we kept on through an afternoon of errands and the walk home after, without the ache a stiff snow boot leaves in your arches.
Sizing is the one wrinkle. The fit runs generous for some and exact for others, so if you are between sizes, try the smaller one first with the socks you will actually wear. One small thing we noticed is the top of the shaft, which has no pull loop, so getting them on takes a second longer than it should; loosen the laces first and it is fine.
What you are paying for is a boot that behaves the same in February as it did in November, and that is worth something on a dark morning. It is the pair we pull on when the forecast is genuinely ugly, and the one that goes back by the door afterwards rather than into the back of the closet.
Pros
- Warm without overheating indoors or on the move
- Stays dry through snow, slush and wet pavement
- Comfortable for long days on foot
Cons
- Tread is not secure on hard, glazed ice
- Bulkier than a town boot
We think the Ice Maiden II is the safest buy here for a wet, cold winter: warm without turning clammy, dry in slush, and comfortable enough to keep on all day.