Best Overall
Columbia Watertight II
Key details
- Model
- 153389
- Style
- Rain jacket
- Department
- Men's
Every other jacket here gets compared to this one, and none of them has knocked it off. The Watertight II is a plain waterproof shell that does the unglamorous thing well: it keeps a long, steady rain off your back, packs into a daypack, and doesn't cook you on the walk home. If you want one jacket for a wet climate and you're not chasing a look, this is the one we point to.
Packability is what keeps it in rotation. It rolls up smaller than any of the lined coats here, dries fast once you're indoors, and blocks wind on an exposed ridge without turning into a sauna when you step into a shop. The hood sits close enough to stay up in weather, and the fabric has enough body that it hangs like a jacket rather than a bag.
The one thing to get right is size. The body and sleeves run generous, so if you're between sizes and won't layer much, take the smaller one; if you plan to wear a fleece under it from October onward, keep your usual. Otherwise there's little to negotiate. It's a shell, it doesn't pretend to be a coat, and the money goes into the waterproofing rather than insulation.
Pros
- Keeps water out through sustained rain
- Packs small enough for a daypack
- Blocks wind without overheating indoors
- Dries quickly between showers
Cons
- Unlined
This is the jacket we tell most people to buy: a proper waterproof shell that handles an all-day rain and disappears into a daypack afterward.