Best Overall
Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper
Key details
- Length
- 6 in
- Weight
- 1 oz
- Lure Type
- Topwater pencil popper
- Running Depth
- Surface
Six inches of bone-colored plastic with the lead pushed back into the tail doesn't look like much in the package. What that weight placement buys is the thing that decides most surf and open-water striper trips: distance. Of the baits here, this is the one drawn specifically for striped bass, from the blunt nose to the tail that sits low on the cast.
It does two jobs on the water. Walk it with a steady rod-tip rhythm and it slides side to side like a spook; lean on the rod and it splashes and spits like a popper. We like having both on the same plug on a morning when we haven't worked out whether the fish want commotion or something quiet. Bone is the right finish for daylight and clear water — it stays visible at range against glare.
The limit is the conditions, not the fish. An ounce of plastic can only punch so far into a hard headwind and a building sea, and that's the day the metal jig comes out of the bag instead. In anything reasonable, we haven't thrown a topwater in this group that's easier to walk or that stays on the surface so reliably on a fast retrieve.
Pros
- Designed for striped bass rather than adapted from a bass plug
- Tail weighting adds real casting distance
- Walks like a spook or splashes like a popper
- Holds up to rocks and repeated fish
Cons
- Only works when fish are feeding at the surface
If stripers are showing on the surface, this is the first plug we tie on: it casts farther than anything else here and walks with almost no effort.