Best Overall
Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof
Key details
- Cut
- Mid
- Model
- RXZER23
- Department
- Men's
- Waterproofing
- Waterproof
The Moab 3 Mid is the boot we hand to someone who wants to hike rather than look like a hiker. It's a real mid-cut — a padded collar that steadies the ankle on rocky ground, a footbed that feels broken in on the first mile, and a lugged sole with enough bite for dirt, roots and dry rock. That combination is why it's our top pick: no single number stands out, but nothing it does on a trail is a weak point.
Sizing is the only thing to plan around. The length runs close, so if you're between sizes, go up — the extra room in the toe costs you nothing and saves your toenails on descents. Do that and the fit settles quickly, which is why we don't think these need a break-in walk before a real one. They're also the least fussy boots in this set to live with: the leather wipes clean, the laces run smoothly through the hardware, and nothing about them asks to be babied.
Waterproofing needs a realistic expectation. Rain, wet grass and shallow mud are handled easily; standing water and long soaks are not, and the membrane that keeps water out holds sweat in on a warm climb. Treat the Moab as a three-season trail boot for wet weather rather than a wading boot, and it does everything you asked of it.
What earns it the top spot over the long run is durability. The uppers hold their shape and the sole stays bonded, so a second and third season is realistic rather than optimistic — and at a mid-range price, that's the difference between a good boot and a good buy.
Pros
- Comfortable from the first mile, no break-in walk
- Steady ankle support on rocky, uneven ground
- Holds its shape and sole across seasons
- Handles rain, wet grass and shallow mud
Cons
- Grip drops off on wet, slick rock
We recommend the Moab 3 Mid to anyone whose hiking is three-season trail work in wet weather: comfortable from the first mile, and built to last longer than one season.